What is Counselling and Psychotherapy? Part 2

In part 1 I explained the process of counselling and psychotherapy and highlighted the most important elements. In part two I will explore the difference between counselling and psychotherapy.  A quick google search will tell you that “counselling and psychotherapy both involve a trained professional helping individuals explore their thoughts, feelings and behaviours to improve mental wellbeing. According to Google, psychotherapy typically focuses on deeper, longer-term issues while counselling addresses more immediate, specific challenges.” This correlates with the definition given by the Irish Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy (IACP) and training provider ICHAS. This is a very simplistic, and in my view, problematic definition of what is a very complex subject. For a start I question the idea that a counsellor can work on any issue with a client and not go deeper. What has happened in the past greatly influences both what is happening in the present and will happen in the future. If we ignore this, we do our clients a disservice.

My search for clarity on this and my firm belief that we need to look backwards so that we can understand how to move forwards, led me to an article on counselling training in higher education in the UK (Joseph, Holford & Murphy, 2018). This article highlighted the difficulty in evaluating counselling research because it crosses the departments of education, social work and psychology. To understand where counselling might fit best, the authors looked at the origins of the field and the developments since. Psychotherapy originated in Freud’s work in the late 19th century and was developed to be used under the direction of medically trained psychiatrists with the assistance of psychologists. Today, it remains commonplace for psychologists and psychiatrists who specialise in psychotherapy to use the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) to diagnose patients in order to provide the recommended treatment/intervention.  In contrast, counselling emerged in the shadow of psychiatry but in opposition to it. In 1954, Abraham Maslow mapped out a new psychology that described people as self-actualising beings, striving towards achieving their unique potential. This humanistic psychology explores what people can achieve when at their very best and is concerned with the full development of human function.

Carl Rogers further developed these ideas into person centred therapy. Frustrated by the fact that the term psychotherapy was reserved only for those with medical training, Rogers used the term counsellor to signify a non-medical but psychological professional. Rogers proposed that people are born with a natural tendency towards exploration, growth, and achievement of their full potential. He proposed that what the medical profession describes as mental illness is a result of normal human development becoming thwarted by controlling and conditional socialisation processes. A client-centred counsellor is explicitly rejecting the idea that therapy is a medical intervention designed to treat psychological disorders. Instead, they offer themselves as facilitators of human growth and development.

Influenced by Rogers, the civil rights movement, and feminism, the profession of counselling emerged in the UK and Ireland from the 1970’s onward, separate from psychiatry or psychology, with no training in medicine or psychology necessary. Over time, the meaning of the term counselling expanded in such a way that its distinction from psychotherapy became less clear cut.  Although the differences and similarities between counselling and psychotherapy remain a topic of contention, most contentious is the different stances represented by the medical model on one hand, and the humanistic approach on the other. The implication of this contention is that accreditation bodies, training facilities and the impending regulatory authority currently in establishment in Ireland have a difficult job to do. And I see a worrying trend occurring that the value of pure humanistic counselling is being increasingly eroded by the narrative that so-called evidence-based, scientifically researched psychotherapy practices are superior and more effective. Even those who appear to agree with Rogers’ views on what humanistic counselling should be, have become critical of this model’s effectiveness on its own. Current training programs are advocating for integrating person centred counselling with more directive models, bringing it closer to the medical model.  These models are being scientifically researched, usually using a very narrow lens. How can you accurately scientifically quantify the nuances of a relationship where healing and change are the primary focus? There are far too many variables to quantify, especially when a lot of the healing is not through what is said, but through what is felt.

This under appreciation of the power of counselling in its pure form is happening at a time when it is needed more than ever. We need to change this narrative that counselling is merely a short-term solution for minor mental health problems back to Rogers original vision. Our collective mental health is in a worse state than it has ever been with people in crisis being turned away from emergency services due to a lack of capacity. The waiting lists for psychiatrists and psychologists are getting bigger, making waiting times longer. Our mental health services are underfunded and under-resourced resulting in many people not getting the care they need before hitting crisis point. For those who do make it into the system there is a good chance they will be medicated and sent home with very little support. They may get an appointment to see their psychiatrist every three months for a quick medication review and that is it. Some of the lucky ones receive some form of psychotherapy but a lot don’t and are left to fend for themselves while quite heavily medicated, putting huge pressure on families. If counselling was valued, widely prescribed, available and affordable, we could start to help people long before they reach crisis point. This would ease the pressure on acute services, making it possible for them to provide a more substantial service than they currently can.

Many high profile mental health professionals who have trained and worked within the medical model for years are starting to reject it. I will explore this in my next blog as I look to the future of counselling and psychotherapy.

References:

Joseph, S., Murphy, D., Holford, J. (2018). Counselling Training in Higher Education in the United Kingdom: Challenges and Opportunity for Research. Counselling and Psychotherapy Research.